Can I break a contract if the other party fails to deliver?

Can I break a contract if the other party fails to deliver?

You’ve paid a deposit for a new kitchen, but the installer hasn’t turned up. Or a supplier promised stock by Friday and now says it might arrive next month. Can you cancel the contract?

In Australia, the answer is sometimes. A missed delivery date does not automatically let you walk away. Your options depend on what the contract says, how serious the failure is, and whether consumer law applies.

First, check what was promised

Look at the written contract, quote, order confirmation and any agreed changes. Was there a firm delivery date, or just an estimate? Does the contract say what happens if either party is late? It may require you to give written notice and an opportunity to fix the problem before cancelling.

For example, if a couch was estimated to arrive “in six to eight weeks” and arrives a few days late, that may not justify cancellation. If the seller agreed it must arrive before an event and knew that timing was essential, a missed date could be much more significant.

How serious is the failure?

Contract law generally distinguishes between a minor breach and a breach serious enough to justify ending the contract. A breach simply means someone has not done what they agreed to do. A major failure to deliver—such as refusing to supply the goods at all—may give you a right to terminate, meaning end the contract. A short delay may give you a right to compensation without giving you a right to cancel.

If there is no agreed delivery date, the other party may still have to perform within a reasonable time. What is reasonable depends on the circumstances: custom-made furniture will usually take longer than an item shown as ready to ship.

Be careful if the other party says they will not perform. That may itself be grounds to end the contract, but it is worth getting advice before acting. Cancelling when you do not have the right to do so can put you in breach instead.

Consumer law may give you extra rights

If you bought goods or services as a consumer, the Australian Consumer Law provides guarantees that apply regardless of a business’s “no refunds” policy. Among other things, services must be supplied within a reasonable time if no timeframe was agreed.

If a business fails to meet a consumer guarantee, your remedy depends on whether the failure is major or can be fixed. For a failure that can be fixed, the business generally gets a reasonable opportunity to do so. For a major failure, you may be able to cancel the service and obtain a refund for the unused portion, or reject goods and seek a refund or replacement, subject to the rules that apply to your purchase. You may also be able to claim compensation for reasonably foreseeable loss caused by the failure.

These rights can be different if the transaction is private or the purchase is for business purposes, so check which rules apply.

What should you do next?

1. Keep the evidence. Save the contract, receipts, messages, promised dates and records of any losses.2. Write to the other party. Explain what has not been delivered, ask for a definite solution, and give a reasonable deadline to respond or perform. Follow any notice process in the contract.3. State the remedy you want. This might be delivery by a new date, a refund, or compensation. Avoid saying you are terminating until you are confident you can.4. Limit your losses. If you need a replacement, take reasonable steps to avoid unnecessary extra costs and keep the receipts.

If you cannot resolve it directly, your state or territory consumer protection agency may be able to help with a consumer dispute. For a high-value contract or a disputed right to cancel, get legal advice before taking the final step.

Hi, I'm Lex. What's your legal question?

Send questions about your legal issue and Asklex will analyse your case via chat.

Scroll to Top